Tarte Sugar Rush Eyeliner Review

tarte eyeliner

Tarte Sugar Rush Eyeliner Clay Liner Pencils are often touted as being the perfect liner. The creamy formula from Tarte Cosmetics has instantly made it to the list of fav products among beauty enthusiasts. Tarte Cosmetics is already a cult favorite, so it didn’t take long for this product to make it to the top of the list. Is it really worth the hype though? Find out with this complete Tarte review!

I do participate in affiliate programs, including Amazon Affiliates, and may earn a small commission if products are purchased through links on the site.

Ingredients Of Tarte Sugar Rush Easy On The Eyes Clay Liner In Bronze

Tarte Cosmetics always makes their ingredient lists available with their product so that you can see what is in the product itself. According to Tarte Cosmetics, the ingredients in Sugar Rush Eyeliner in Bronze include:

Cyclopentasiloxane, trimethylsiloxysilicate, synthetic wax, polyethylene, isododecane, mica, ceresin, polyglyceryl-2 triisostearate, aluminum hydroxide, polyisobutene, dimethicone, methicone, kaolin. (+/-): Titanium Dioxide (CI 77891), manganese violet (CI 77742), ultramarines (CI77007).

However, because ingredients and formulas change over time, it’s always a great idea to check your package if you are allergic to or want to avoid specific ingredients.


tarte cosmetics

When I first heard about this product from Tarte Cosmetics, it was described as the perfect eyeliner. I was a bit skeptical. There is no perfect eyeliner. However, there are so many great things about this one that it is pretty close to perfection.

Tarte Sugar Rush Clay Eyeliner Provides 16-Hour Wear

Tarte Cosmetics advertises that this eyeliner will stay put for 16 hours, and they are right. This clay eyeliner pencil tends to dry similar to liquid liner. If you touch it before it dries, expect it to smudge away. However, if you wait a minute or so, you’ll find that it’s actually a challenge to get the eyeliner off.

All-Day Waterproof Eyeliner

Not only does this eyeliner last all day, but it’s also waterproof. You can easily wear it out in the rain without having raccoon eyes by the time you walk in the door.

Built-In Sharpener

The built-in sharpener is the perfect thing for all of your gel or clay eyeliners that need sharpened. It does not cut into the pencil and is the perfect size to give your pencil a pointed shape.

Creamy Clay Pencil Liner Offers Easy Application

This eye product is one of the most popular products for a reason. It glides on so smoothly that it’s perfect for both novices and makeup experts. The way that it glides across your eyelid makes application a breeze. You get all of the benefits of a liquid eyeliner without the hassle that it brings to the table.

Limited Edition Shades And Everyday Tarte Sugar Rush Shades Available

The limited edition shades are gorgeous, but you can always find this eyeliner in a couple of colors at Ulta too. The black color is super black. Bronze delivers a beautiful color too! The traditional neutral shades are the couple of colors that you always need in your eyeliner arsenal.

Product Is Available In Travel Size

Makeup products tend to take up a lot of space when you’re traveling. On top of that, spending the money on a full size product that you might never use more than once can add up to spending too much money on makeup. If you’re not sure about the eyeliner or need a smaller version, you can get that with the travel size eyeliner.


Before apply this eyeliner, simply put a swipe on your arm. Let it dry. Then, try to smudge it away. This clay pencil eyeliner is genuinely smudge proof!

Transfer Free Eyeliner

Because it’s smudge proof, it’s the perfect eyeliner for hooded eyes or other people that need a transfer free eyeliner.

No Tug

The skin around your eyes is so delicate. Simply tuggin on the skin daily to stretch it out for the perfect winged eyeliner can result in wrinkles and sagging skin over time. That won’t be a problem anymore thanks to eye liners like this one. The Tarte Sugar Rush Easy on the Eyes Clay Liner glides on without pulling on the skin.

Highly Pigmented Colors

Not only is the Tarte Sugar Rush Easy on the Eyes liner great for your eyes, it looks gorgeous. The beautiful colors are a brighter color than your average pencil liner. This clay liner makes natural shades pop with personality.


tarte eyeliner

Although this liner is close to perfection, there are a few things to keep in mind before picking one up. As with everything, there are always good and not so good things about a product.

Liner Is Very Soft

The liner is so creamy that the pencil is unbelievably soft. If you’ve never used a clay eyeliner before, it’s important to keep this in mind. Pushing down too hard can mean that your eyeliner instantly needs to be sharpened again. The same applies to pushing it into the sharpener a bit too hard. You need to use a light hand when working with a clay liner.

It Can Be A Bit Too Creamy

Because the liner is a clay liner, it can be so creamy for beginners that it can make application a little difficult. Apply it with a light, steady hand until you get the hang of using a liner like this.

Not Good For Precise Lines

Tarte Sugar Rush Easy On The Eyes Clay Eyeliner is wonderful, but it’s so soft that it’s impossible to keep the tip pointed enough to deliver precise lines. If you prefer micro liners for your winged eyeliner, keep this in mind before picking up one of these.

Should You Buy Tarte Sugar Rush Easy On The Eyes Liner?

If you want a liner that is like a liquid eyeliner but not as difficult to apply, this one is for you. It has a high color pay off with almost no effort required on your part.

This eyeliner is an exceptional idea for anyone that needs a smudge proof liner as well. According to some eyeliner reviews, the product wipes right off. It does, but that’s only if you don’t let it dry first. If you have oily eyelinds, don’t forget your primer to keep it in place!

This eyeliner is advertised as being gluten free, but it’s not advised that you buy it if you’re very sensitive to gluten in your eye products. Tarte says that cross contamination might be an issue. Because of that, you may wind up with an eyeliner that has trace elements of gluten, and you may develop an allergic reaction.


Is Tarte makeup gluten free?

Yes, it is! The website clearly states that all Tarte products are carefully formulated with gluten. However, they do clearly state that there can be cross contamination. This means that the products may be processed in a facility and still have trace amounts of gluten in them.

Is Tarte cosmetics vegan friendly?

Yes, Tarte cosmetics are vegan friendly for the most part. However, you do need to note that all of their products are not vegan. Because of that, you need to double check product descriptions and the packaging.

It is noted when products are vegan. If there is nothing that says a product is vegan, it’s safe to assume that it’s not.

Tarte Sugar Rush Easy On The Eyes Clay Liner in Bronze is vegan, by the way.

Is Tarte cruelty free?

Yes, Tarte is cruelty free. They do not do testing on animals, and their ingredients are also not tested on animals. Tarte products are not sold where animal testing is required by law, either. You can find the adorable bunny logo on Tarte packaging.

In Conclusion

Tarte Sugar Rush Easy On The Eyes Clay Eyeliner is an awesome product if you need something that is waterproof, smudge proof and will last all day. It’s the perfect eyeliner for beginners! You can always find it online at Ulta. However, if you need precision for a wing flip, this might not be the best product for you. Instead, check out liquid eyeliners like this one.

Related Articles

Tarte Creaseless Concealer Review

Best Drugstore Eyeliner

ELF Eyeliner Pen Review

Girlactik Eyeliner Review (Perfect Duo Eyeliner)

Leave a Reply

The author does not in any way guarantee or warrant the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any message and will not be held responsible for the content of any message. Always consult your personal physician for specific medical advice. Information on this blog is for informational/entertainment use only. Please be advised that I do participate in affiliate programs, and may earn a commission if you purchase products by clicking on links on this website.