Julep is known for consistently providing high-quality products, from their cult-favorite eyeshadow sticks to their soothing Rosehip Facial Oil. Most of their products have been around for years, but they’ve experienced buy outs, new branding, developed sister brands, and more. Is their eyeliner still one of the best? Find out in this honest Julep When Pencil Met Gel Eyeliner review. 

I participate in affiliate programs, including Amazon Affiliates, and may earn a small commission if you purchase items through the site’s links. 

Key Features

Julep When Pencil Met Gel Eyeliner Pencil glides smoothly across the skin like your favorite gel eyeliners, but stays put and is easy to use like pencil products. You truly get the best of both worlds. Some features you’ll love include: 

• No Tugging: This eyeliner pencil doesn’t tug on your eyelid like pencil eyeliners do. Instead, it glides smoothly across the eyelid for seamless application. 
• Shades Available: There are so many shades available, there truly is something for everyone. You can find any shade you want in either a matte or shimmer finish to get the look you want. 
• Smudgable: The eyeliner takes time to dry (about 30-40 seconds), which makes it perfect for a smudged look. It dries fast enough that it won’t slow down your morning routine if you want a crisp line but slow enough to smudge it for a smokey eye. 

The complete ingredient list is available on the Julep website. Remember that it’s different for various shades, so it’s crucial to look at the list for the shade you’re interested in. 

Pros

Smooth Application

When Pencil Met Gel Eyeliner offers a smooth application that you simply don’t get when you use eyeliner pencils. Instead, it glides across your eyelids like butter for a seamless application process. 

Multiple Colors Available

You can easily find any color you’d like to create your dream look. There are over twenty different colors available, and matte and shimmer finishes. 

Serious Pigment

When Julep says something has a lot of pigment, they mean it. Every color, including nude and white shades, delivers plenty of pigment to help you get an impressive look with just one swipe. 

Long-Lasting

A unique formula helps this gel pencil last all day long. I put mine on at eight in the morning, and the color was still there, unsmudged, when I was ready to wipe it off ten hours later. 

Easy to Remove

I use a Makeup Eraser at the end of the day, and it was easy to wipe away this eyeliner. Surprisingly, it stayed on all day and came off without me having to scrub. It should be easy to remove with other makeup removers, too. 

Cons

Pain To Sharpen

These gel pencils aren’t the easiest to get a precise point with. Cheap drugstore sharpeners don’t seem to get the job done. Instead, you have to use a good sharpener, and don’t apply too much pressure to get the perfect point. 

Should You Buy It?

Julep When Pencil Met Gel Eyeliner is definitely worth the price. You can easily sharpen it with the torpedo shaped sharpener to get the perfect point for whatever look you want. If black is too harsh for you, gorgeous nude and brown shades are available. Both shimmer and matte shades set perfectly for a flawless look that lasts all day. Check it out here!

Related Articles

Does Eyeliner Stain Clothes?

Does Eyeliner Age You

Can You Wear Eyeliner Without Eyeshadow?