Can You Use Brow Pencil as Eyeliner? -

While brow pencils and eyeliners are designed for different purposes, they share many similarities, such as their pencil form and ability to create defined lines. However, there are differences in texture, formula, and pigmentation that may affect how well a brow pencil works as an eyeliner. Here’s a closer look at the pros and cons of using brow pencil as eyeliner, and how to do it effectively.

I participate in affiliate programs, including Amazon Affiliates, and may earn a small commission if you purchase items through the site’s links.

Similarities Between Brow Pencils and Eyeliners

Brow pencils and eyeliners are both used to define and shape specific areas of the face. Many makeup products today are versatile, allowing for multi-use purposes. Here’s why a brow pencil might work as an eyeliner:

Shape and Texture: Brow pencils and eyeliners are often similar in shape and texture, making it easy to use them interchangeably. They both come in pencil or twist-up forms and are designed to create sharp, defined lines.
Pigmentation: While brow pencils are usually less pigmented than eyeliners, they can still provide a natural, soft look around the eyes, which can be appealing for those who want a more subtle effect.

Pros of Using Brow Pencil as Eyeliner

If you’re in a pinch or prefer a softer look, using a brow pencil as eyeliner can be a quick fix. Here are some benefits:

Natural Look: Brow pencils are designed to mimic the natural appearance of brow hairs, which means they often create a more muted, softer line when used as eyeliner. This can be ideal for those who prefer a subtle look or for daytime wear.
Multipurpose Product: Brow pencils are versatile, so having one product that works as both an eyebrow definer and an eyeliner can save space in your makeup bag.
Long-Wearing: Brow pencils are usually designed to last all day on your brows, which means they often have long-lasting formulas that may also stay put on your eyes.

Cons of Using Brow Pencil as Eyeliner

While using a brow pencil as eyeliner can work in certain situations, there are some drawbacks to consider:

Texture Differences: Brow pencils are often waxier and less pigmented than eyeliners. This texture is ideal for filling in brows but might not glide as smoothly on your eyelids. The waxy formula may also tug or pull on the delicate skin around your eyes, making it harder to achieve a precise line.
Color Limitations: Brow pencils, like browns or taupes, typically come in neutral shades to match natural brow colors. If you’re looking for a bold, black eyeliner or colorful eye looks, a brow pencil may not provide the intensity you want.
Potential for Smudging: Brow pencils are not always formulated to be smudge-proof when used on the eyelids. Depending on the formula, it may smudge or fade faster than an eyeliner explicitly designed for the eyes.

How to Use Brow Pencil as Eyeliner

If you decide to use your brow pencil as eyeliner, here’s how to do it effectively for the best results:

Prep the Eye Area: Start with a clean, moisturized eyelid. Applying a primer can help prevent smudging and ensure the product lasts longer.
Apply the Brow Pencil: Use the brow pencil to gently trace along your upper lash line. Because the formula is softer, it’s best to stick close to the lash line for a natural look. You can also apply the pencil to your lower lash line for a more defined eye.
Smudge for a Softer Look: Brow pencils often have a softer texture, so after applying, use a smudging brush or a clean finger to gently soften the line for a smoky, blended effect.
Set with Powder: To prevent the brow pencil from smudging or fading throughout the day, set it with a neutral or brown eyeshadow over the top. This will help lock in the product and create a more long-lasting effect.

Alternatives to Using Brow Pencil as Eyeliner

If you frequently find yourself using brow pencil as eyeliner but want a product better suited for the eyes, here are some alternatives to consider:

Kohl or Gel Pencils: These types of eyeliners offer smooth application and rich pigmentation, making them perfect for lining the eyes.
Eyeshadow as Eyeliner: You can use a small angled brush to apply eyeshadow along your lash line for a soft, smoky look. This gives a similar soft effect as a brow pencil but with better color variety.
Gel Liner: If you’re looking for something that gives a more precise and defined line, a gel eyeliner applied with an angled brush can offer a long-lasting, bold look.

Is It Safe to Use Brow Pencil as Eyeliner?

In general, most brow pencils are safe to use as eyeliner, especially if they are formulated for sensitive skin. However, always check the label to ensure the product is free from harmful chemicals or irritants, particularly if you have sensitive eyes. Avoid using very old or dried-out brow pencils on your eyes, as they can cause irritation or tugging.