While natural makeup brushes, typically made from animal hair, offer advantages like better blending and product pickup, they also come with drawbacks. If you’re trying to decide between natural and synthetic brushes, it’s essential to consider the downsides of using natural brushes. Here’s a look at the cons of natural makeup brushes.
I participate in affiliate programs, including Amazon Affiliates, and may earn a small commission if you purchase items through the site’s links.
Not Cruelty-Free
One of the most significant concerns with natural makeup brushes is that they are made from animal hair. Even if the brand claims to source hair ethically, it’s difficult to guarantee that the animals involved weren’t harmed or mistreated. For those committed to cruelty-free beauty, this is a major reason to avoid natural brushes.
Why It Matters: If you prioritize ethical beauty choices, synthetic brushes are a better alternative as they are 100% cruelty-free.
You can also research the company. Many cruelty-free companies are certified by PETA. Double-check to see if a company is certified cruelty-free to determine if animal hair is sourced ethically before purchasing natural makeup brushes.
Higher Price Point
Natural makeup brushes tend to be more expensive than their synthetic counterparts due to the sourcing and production of animal hair. While they can be considered an investment, the cost can be a deterrent, especially for those just starting to build their makeup kit or working with a limited budget.
Why It Matters: Synthetic brushes that perform just as well but are cheaper might offer better value for your money.
Allergies and Sensitivities
Some individuals may experience allergies or sensitivities to the animal hair used in natural brushes. Animal hair can sometimes irritate sensitive skin or cause allergic reactions, especially for those allergic to specific types of fur, such as goat or squirrel.
Why It Matters: Using synthetic brushes can help avoid skin irritation and allergic reactions if you have sensitive skin or known allergies.
More Maintenance Required
Natural hair, like human hair, is more porous and absorbs oils, products, and dirt more easily. This means natural brushes require more frequent and thorough cleaning than synthetic brushes. If not properly cleaned, they can harbor bacteria, leading to breakouts and skin irritation.
You will notice the same thing if you don’t clean synthetic makeup brushes. However, it tends to be more so when it comes to natural makeup brushes.
Why It Matters: If you’re not diligent about cleaning your makeup tools, natural brushes can accumulate product buildup, reducing their lifespan and impacting your skin’s health.
Not Ideal for Liquid or Cream Products
While natural brushes are excellent for powder products, they don’t perform as well with liquid or cream formulas. The porous nature of animal hair can absorb liquid products, leading to waste and making the application uneven or streaky. Synthetic brushes, on the other hand, are designed to work well with both liquid—and cream-based products.
Why It Matters: If you use a lot of liquid foundation, concealer, or cream blush, synthetic brushes are a better choice for an even, streak-free finish.
Our Picks
Beautyblender® | Original Pink + Nude Beauty Blender
BS-MALL Makeup Brush Set 18 Pcs
Can Shed More Easily
Natural hair brushes are more prone to shedding than synthetic brushes. Over time, the bristles may come loose, reducing the brush’s effectiveness and leaving stray hairs on your face during makeup application. While proper care can extend their life, shedding can still be problematic for many natural brushes.
Why It Matters: Regular shedding can make your brushes less effective and frustrating, requiring more frequent replacements.
Environmental Impact
Although natural brushes are made from animal hair, which is biodegradable, the impact of sourcing and harvesting these materials can be less environmentally friendly. Synthetic brushes, made from man-made fibers, are more eco-friendly when sourced from brands focused on sustainability and ethical production practices.
Why It Matters: If you’re focused on sustainability, choosing eco-friendly synthetic brushes may better align with your environmental values.
Are Natural Makeup Brushes Worth It?
While natural makeup brushes offer great blending capabilities for powder products, their drawbacks—such as ethical concerns, higher maintenance, and limitations with liquid products—should be considered. For many makeup users, synthetic brushes can provide the same or better performance without the downsides associated with animal hair.
If you value cruelty-free, allergy-safe, and versatile makeup tools, synthetic brushes might be the better choice for your beauty routine. Check out the rest of the site to learn more!
Related Articles
How To Clean Dense Makeup Brushes
How Long Do Makeup Brushes Last