Half Caked is an indie makeup brand founded by two sisters in Tampa, Florida. The name, “Half Caked,” comes from their childhood sharing everything, hence “half” of everything, even the cake.
The brand officially launched on Valentine’s Day in 2016 with their now-popular mousse-to-matte Lip Fondants, and since then, they’ve expanded into lip glosses, palettes, mascaras, blushes, bronzers, and more. Their aesthetic leans sweet, playful, and nostalgic, with a focus on fun names, pastel or dessert-inspired design, and high color payoff.
I participate in affiliate programs, including Amazon Affiliates, and may earn a small commission if you purchase items through the site’s links.
What Half Caked Does Well
One of Half Caked’s biggest strengths is its ethical positioning. The brand is PETA-certified cruelty-free and vegan. Their product pages clearly state that no ingredients are animal-derived or tested on animals, and that they require animal non-testing declarations from their manufacturers. This makes Half Caked a solid choice for consumers who prioritize clean, animal-friendly beauty.
Another area where Half Caked impresses is in its formula and pigment quality. Reviews of their Lip Fondant line, for example, frequently praise the shade range, color intensity, and staying power.
Many users consider these lip products to be long-wearing, with minimal transfer or fading. Their other product lines, like their liquid blush (“In Sync”) and cream bronzers, also carry this theme of vibrant, wearable color.
Another appealing factor is the fun packaging and branding. Half Caked embraces whimsy; its product names, scents (often cake or dessert inspired), and design all lean into that identity. For many users, that adds extra enjoyment: unboxing, swatching, and using the products feel like more than utility; they’re part of a sensory, playful experience.
The price point is also reasonable for the quality offered. While not ultra-cheap, Half Caked tends to land in the mid-indie range where many find they get good value for pigment, wear time, and design. The brand seems to cater particularly well to people who want expressive color without spending luxury-brand prices.
Where Half Caked Has Room to Improve
No brand is perfect, and Half Caked does show some limitations, especially depending on what you expect.
One common complaint is texture or dryness. Some of the Liquid Lip Fondants are noted to be drying if lips aren’t well-prepared (moisturized or exfoliated). Users sometimes mention needing to use gloss or balm over the top to combat that.
Wear-time can also vary. While many reviews praise longevity and minimal transfer, others say the color might fade or wear off with drinking, eating, or extended wear, especially if not applied properly (e.g. layering or letting product set fully).
Some users also find that certain formulas (especially glosses) can be sticky. For gloss lovers, that might be fine; for others, it’s a downside. Packaging durability can sometimes be questioned (applicators breaking or packaging being a bit delicate), though these issues don’t dominate overall feedback.
Verdict: Is Half Caked a Good Brand?
Yes, Half Caked is a good brand, especially if you value ethical beauty, playful design, and pigmented, fun makeup. It nails the vegan/cruelty-free components, offers engaging packaging and names, and delivers formulas that many people enjoy and find durable. If you’re someone who wants expressive lip colors, vibrant shadows, or sweet scent-inspired product experiences, Half Caked will likely satisfy.
If your expectations are focused on ultra-long wear under the most demanding conditions, maximum comfort (especially for drier lips), or rock-solid packaging, there may be better fits. But those trade-offs are quite normal at the price point and with Indie brands.
Related Articles