When it comes to long-lasting manicures, Shellac and dip nails are two of the most popular choices. Both promise glossy, chip-resistant color that outlasts regular polish, but they’re actually very different in how they’re applied, how they wear, and how they’re removed.
I participate in affiliate programs, including Amazon Associates, and may earn a small commission if you purchase items through the site’s links.
What Is Shellac
Shellac is a hybrid between gel and traditional nail polish, created by CND (Creative Nail Design). It’s applied like regular polish but cured under a UV or LED lamp, which helps it harden instantly and stay glossy for up to two weeks.
Shellac combines the flexibility of polish with the durability of gel. It doesn’t require any powder or resin, and it feels thinner and lighter on the nails than acrylics or dip systems.
How it’s applied:
- Nails are cleaned and shaped.
- A base coat is applied and cured under a lamp.
- Two layers of Shellac color are painted on and cured after each coat.
- A top coat is added and cured again.
Once cured, the result is a smooth, high-shine finish that resists chipping better than traditional nail polish.
What Is Dip Powder
Dip powder nails, sometimes called SNS or dipping powder nails, are created by layering colored acrylic powder and resin on the nails instead of polish.
The process doesn’t require UV light; instead, it uses a special adhesive base coat that bonds the powder to your nail. Dip powder nails are thicker and stronger than Shellac, making them ideal for anyone who wants durability and long wear.
How it’s applied:
- Nails are prepped and dehydrated to remove oils.
- A base coat or adhesive resin is brushed on.
- The nail is dipped into colored powder or the powder is sprinkled over the nail.
- The process is repeated for coverage and strength.
- A sealant or top coat is applied for shine.
Dip nails usually last three to four weeks and have a sturdier feel than Shellac.
Key Differences Between Shellac and Dip
While both offer long-lasting results, Shellac and dip powder are not the same. Here’s how they differ in several important ways:
1. Formula and Materials
- Shellac: A blend of gel and polish that cures under light.
- Dip: Colored acrylic powder bonded with adhesive resin.
Shellac is more like a polish, while dip powder is more like a lightweight acrylic.
2. Application Process
- Shellac: Painted on and cured under UV or LED light.
- Dip: Applied using resin and powder; no curing light needed.
Shellac feels like a traditional manicure with extra durability, while dip nails involve layers of powder and resin for added strength.
3. Thickness and Feel
- Shellac: Thin and flexible, ideal for a natural look.
- Dip: Thicker and stronger, with a more reinforced feel.
If you like your nails to feel light and natural, Shellac may be your match. For those who need extra strength or length, dip powder is more durable.
4. Durability and Longevity
- Shellac: Lasts about two weeks before showing wear.
- Dip: Can last up to four weeks without chipping.
Dip nails hold up longer, especially for people who use their hands often or have weaker natural nails.
5. Removal Process
- Shellac: Soaked off with acetone for 10–15 minutes.
- Dip: Buffed down and soaked longer, often 20–30 minutes.
Both require acetone, but dip powder can be harder to remove because it’s thicker and more solid.
6. Nail Health and Maintenance
- Shellac: Easier on the nails if removed properly.
- Dip: Can be damaging if overfilled or peeled off.
Proper removal is key for both, but dip nails require extra care to avoid thinning the natural nail underneath.
Benefits of Shellac
Shellac is popular for its light, glossy finish and natural feel. It’s a great middle ground between regular polish and gel nails.
Benefits include:
- Quick application and removal
- Less bulky than acrylic or dip
- No filing down the natural nail
- Natural-looking shine
- No need for powder or glue
It’s ideal for anyone who wants a durable manicure without the thickness or long removal process of dip nails.
Benefits of Dip Powder
Dip powder nails stand out for their strength and staying power. They’re perfect for people who are tough on their nails or want manicures that last for weeks.
Benefits include:
- Extremely durable and chip-resistant
- Can last three to four weeks
- No UV light required
- Great for strengthening weak nails
- Can be built up for longer nail shapes
Dip powder is also a good choice for anyone who wants bold, opaque color and extra protection for brittle nails.
Which Is Healthier for Nails
Both Shellac and dip powder can be safe when applied and removed correctly. The main concern with either is improper removal — peeling or scraping can damage the nail plate.
Shellac tends to be gentler because it’s thinner and easier to remove. Dip powder can cause more stress on the nail if the layers are thick or if the nails are soaked too long in acetone.
To protect your nails, it’s best to:
- Avoid picking or peeling the polish.
- Use cuticle oil daily.
- Let nails breathe between manicures.
- Go to a trained technician for removal.
If your nails are sensitive or thin, Shellac may be the better choice for less stress on the nail bed.
Appearance and Finish
Both Shellac and dip powder come in a wide range of colors and finishes, but they look slightly different on the nail.
- Shellac: Has a sleek, glassy shine with a smooth texture.
- Dip powder: Can appear thicker and more opaque with a dense color payoff.
Shellac is great for those who love a natural, glossy look. Dip powder offers a more structured, salon-style appearance that resembles acrylics.
Cost and Maintenance
Shellac manicures typically cost $30 to $50 at a salon, while dip powder manicures range from $40 to $60, depending on the design and brand.
Shellac is faster to apply and remove, making it ideal for quick touch-ups. Dip powder takes longer but lasts nearly twice as long, making it more cost-effective over time.
For at-home manicures, both require some investment in products and tools, but dip systems can be a bit more involved due to powder application and sealing steps.
Who Should Choose Shellac
Choose Shellac if you:
- Want a natural, lightweight finish
- Prefer faster removal
- Don’t need extreme durability
- Want a glossy manicure that feels like polish
Shellac is also perfect for those who change nail colors often or prefer a more flexible, comfortable manicure.
Who Should Choose Dip
Choose dip powder if you:
- Need longer-lasting wear (3–4 weeks)
- Want extra strength for weak nails
- Prefer a thick, solid color finish
- Don’t mind a longer removal process
Dip nails are ideal for anyone who wants maximum longevity and doesn’t plan to change their manicure frequently.
The Bottom Line
So, is Shellac the same as dip? No, but they both have their place in modern nail care.
Shellac is a light, glossy hybrid polish that feels natural and offers quick, beautiful results. Dip powder is a strong, long-wearing acrylic system that provides weeks of chip-free color and protection.
Both can give you salon-worthy nails, but they suit different needs. If you love the feel of natural polish with extra shine, go for Shellac. If you want long-lasting strength and don’t mind a thicker look, dip powder is the way to go.
Related Articles
Is Nail Polish Remover Rubbing Alcohol