Is Maybelline a Good Brand? -

Maybelline is one of the most recognizable names in the world of beauty. Founded in 1915 by a Chicago chemist named Thomas Lyle Williams, the brand started with a simple idea: to create a product that could enhance the lashes.

Over a century later, Maybelline New York has become a global powerhouse under the ownership of L’Oréal, offering affordable and accessible makeup for millions. Beyond its longevity and popularity, is Maybelline truly a good brand?

I participate in affiliate programs, including Amazon Associates, and may earn a small commission if you purchase items through the site’s links.

The Legacy of Maybelline

Maybelline’s story began when Williams noticed his sister using a homemade mixture of Vaseline and coal dust to darken her lashes. Inspired, he created a product called “Lash-Brow-Ine,” and later launched it under the brand name Maybelline: a combination of his sister’s name, Maybel, and Vaseline. Over the decades, the company has evolved from a small family business to one of the world’s top cosmetics brands.

Today, Maybelline offers a diverse range of products, including foundations, concealers, mascaras, and lipsticks. It’s sold in more than 120 countries, and its marketing campaigns are known for featuring models and celebrities who embody confidence and diversity.

The brand’s message, “Make It Happen,” emphasizes empowerment and self-expression: ideas that resonate with consumers across generations.

Product Quality and Performance

One of the primary reasons behind Maybelline’s enduring popularity is the high quality of its products in relation to their price. The brand has become a staple for consumers seeking dependable, high-performing cosmetics without the luxury price tag.

Foundations and Concealers

Maybelline’s Fit Me Foundation line remains one of the most beloved drugstore foundations in the world. Available in matte and dewy formulas, it offers an impressive range of shades for different undertones and skin types. Many makeup enthusiasts and professionals praise its natural finish, blendability, and buildable coverage.

The Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer is another cult favorite, often compared to high-end concealers for its smooth texture and coverage. It’s designed to minimize dark circles and fine lines, and its sponge-tip applicator makes application easy.

Reviewers frequently point out that both the foundation and concealer perform well for their price, rivaling brands that cost two or three times as much.

Mascaras

If there’s one category that defines Maybelline, it’s mascara. From the classic Great Lash to the viral Sky High Mascara, the brand has been synonymous with lash innovation for decades.

The Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara, for instance, became a social media phenomenon for its ability to lift and lengthen lashes without clumping. Its flexible brush and lightweight formula deliver dramatic results while maintaining comfort.

Maybelline’s mascaras consistently rank among the best in both performance and affordability, making them a go-to for beauty lovers around the world.

Lipsticks and Eye Products

Maybelline’s SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipsticks are known for their long wear time and intense pigment. They can last through meals and daily wear with minimal touch-ups, which has earned them glowing reviews.

The brand also offers highly pigmented eyeshadow palettes and eyeliners that blend easily and suit both natural and bold looks. The Tattoo Studio Gel Pencil Liner and Brow Ultra Slim Pencil are especially popular for their precision and staying power.

Accessibility and Affordability

A major factor that contributes to Maybelline’s positive reputation is its accessibility. The brand’s products are available in nearly every drugstore, supermarket, and online retailer. Consumers can easily find Maybelline products worldwide, which gives the brand a level of trust and familiarity that few others can match.

Affordability also plays a key role. Maybelline offers high-quality products at prices that are accessible to a wide audience. This makes it a preferred choice for students, professionals, and makeup artists alike. While the beauty market has seen an influx of new brands in recent years, Maybelline remains a reliable and budget-friendly option.

Ethical and Sustainability Efforts

When it comes to ethics, Maybelline’s track record is mixed. While the brand states that it does not test its products on animals, its parent company L’Oréal sells in markets where animal testing is required by law. This complicates Maybelline’s cruelty-free status.

However, the brand has made progress in areas related to sustainability. Maybelline launched the Conscious Together program, which includes goals like reducing plastic waste, using more recyclable packaging, and improving transparency in ingredient sourcing. The company aims to make 100% of its plastic packaging recyclable or reusable in the near future.

While Maybelline is not fully cruelty-free or vegan, its efforts to adopt more sustainable practices demonstrate that it is evolving in line with consumer expectations. Many of its newer products also avoid certain harsh ingredients, appealing to those who prioritize cleaner formulations.

Customer Satisfaction and Reputation

Consumer feedback remains one of the strongest indicators of a brand’s quality, and Maybelline enjoys consistently positive reviews. Its products frequently appear on “best of” lists from trusted sources like Allure, InStyle, and Glamour.

Customers appreciate the balance between affordability and performance. The consistency of Maybelline’s product quality, particularly in its foundation and mascara lines, keeps people returning to the brand.

That said, some critics point out that not all Maybelline products are created equal. A few formulas, especially older ones, may contain synthetic ingredients or fragrances that can irritate sensitive skin. However, the overall consensus is that Maybelline provides strong value for the price.

Innovation and Trends

Maybelline has shown an impressive ability to stay relevant in a fast-changing beauty industry. The brand often releases trend-forward products that align with modern beauty standards — from dewy skin looks to transfer-proof lipstick formulas.

Social media has played a major role in Maybelline’s continued success. Viral TikTok reviews and YouTube tutorials regularly feature Maybelline products, especially mascaras and foundations. The brand’s presence in influencer marketing helps maintain its relevance among younger audiences while preserving its legacy appeal.

Diversity and Inclusion

In recent years, Maybelline has made efforts to embrace diversity and inclusivity in both its product lines and marketing campaigns. The expansion of foundation shades to include a wide range of skin tones is a notable step forward.

Campaigns featuring models of different ethnicities, genders, and backgrounds reflect a modern and inclusive approach to beauty. This commitment to representation resonates with consumers who value brands that celebrate individuality and authenticity.

Is Maybelline Worth It?

When evaluating whether Maybelline is a “good” brand, several factors come into play: quality, price, accessibility, ethics, and innovation.

Maybelline excels in offering high-performing products that are affordable and widely available. Its formulas are reliable, its shade ranges are improving, and its marketing aligns with current values of diversity and self-expression.

However, consumers seeking cruelty-free or fully vegan options may hesitate to support the brand due to its testing policies in certain regions. Still, many shoppers choose Maybelline for its overall quality, value, and dependable performance.