When you think of a makeup remover, the first question that pops up in your mind is: Is there a makeup remover that will remove all the traces of makeup without giving you the panda eyes? The simple and direct answer to this would be, Yes! However, it takes unlimited trials to get to your holy grail formula that works wonderfully well with all your type and doesn’t worsen your skin condition (if there’s any).
There are hundreds of options that deliver quality and are completely affordable. Brands like Neutrogena, Simple, Julep, Makeup Eraser, and more offer different makeup removers with specific skin type formulations.
To help you pick your favorite makeup removers, we have carefully selected products that will give you the desired results, from makeup erasers and towelettes to cleansing balms and wipes. Everything is just a click away.
Best Waterproof Makeup Removers
The Original MakeUp Eraser ($18)
Pros
- For all skin types, particularly oily skin
- Removes waterproof mascara, eyeliner, foundation, and lipstick
- Water activated: Soak it in lukewarm water before use
- The material is easily washable and reusable
- It makes an ideal travel-friendly option
Cons
- May take a little more effort to remove an entire face of makeup
The Original Makeup Eraser remains one of my all-time favorites for removing waterproof makeup. You can check out a comprehensive Makeup Eraser review to see all the details you need to know! Overall, this is a solid option if you want something quick and sustainable to use.
Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover By GA-DA ($21)
Pros
- Gently removes eye makeup without irritating the delicate skin around the eyes
- Soothes and calms the skin
- Promotes softer skin
- Paraben-free
- Can be used on other areas of the face
Cons
- Water and oil makeup hybrid may not be suitable for people with oily skin
This eye makeup remover is a genius combination of both oil and water. Oil gently lifts away makeup while water helps give your face a clean feeling that you’ll love. GA-DA believes that you should be able to remove your eye makeup in one swipe, and this waterproof eye makeup remover makes that possible!
Make-up Removing Cloths, Erase Your Face By Danielle Creations ($10)
Pros
- Waterproof makeup removing clothes
- For dry, sensitive skin types
- It’s completely reusable
- WATER ACTIVATED: removes makeup, dirt, and oil with lukewarm water
- No additional makeup remover is required
- Travel-friendly
- Multipurpose uses: Can be used to remove skincare products like clay masks.
Cons
- As with The Original Makeup Eraser, you may need to scrub a little bit more to remove a full face of glam makeup, especially glitter makeup
- Price varies depending on the color you want
If you’re searching for a sustainable option, makeup-removing cloths like these are great! They eliminate the need for makeup remover wipes or any makeup remover. All you need are these cloths and lukewarm water. They work similarly to The Original Makeup Eraser. However, one side is not designed specifically for exfoliating your face.
Neutrogena Makeup Remover Eraser Stick ($8)
Pros
- Suitable For all skin types
- Easy to use
- Travel friendly
- Ideal for removing eye makeup( smudged mascara, lipstick, eyeliner) and quick touch-ups on the lids, brows, and lips
- Formulated with Vitamin E (antioxidant source for the skin)
Cons:
- It may not go well with sensitive/acne-prone skin
- Utilizes coconut oil to remove makeup, including waterproof makeup. If coconut oil makes you break out or you have an allergy, this is not the best option.
This travel-friendly makeup removal option is perfect for anyone on the go. You can easily toss it into your purse or suitcase for touch-ups on the go, such as if the new eyeliner you’re trying out leaves you with raccoon eyes. After removing stubborn makeup, including eye makeup, it gently nourishes the skin.
Jojoba Oil Makeup Remover And Cleansing Balm By Dr Liia ($19)
Pros
- Suitable for contact lens wearers
- Works well on sensitive skin
- Soothing and calming
- Removes makeup, including waterproof makeup
- Moisturizes skin
Cons
- Oil-based
While an oil-based makeup remover is great for removing waterproof makeup, they may not work well with acne-prone skin. If you do have acne-prone skin, make sure that you wash away and excess oil on your face to prevent breakouts. Aside from that one downfall, this product does exactly what it says, and comes at a price you can afford.
Vitamin E Cleansing Oil By Julep ($22)
Pros
- Hydrates and protects the skin from things like free radical damage
- Moisturizing properties
- Packed with antioxidants
- Melts away makeup, including waterproof makeup
- Only takes a few pumps per use, meaning this bottle will last you awhile
- Doesn’t require harsh scrubbing that will irritate the skin
Cons
- It does burn if you accidentally get it into your eyes
- Not ideal for acne-prone skin
- Scented
Overall, this is a great waterproof makeup remover as long as you don’t mind a lightly scented product and don’t have acne-prone skin. Because it’s an oil, some people assume it won’t burn your eyes if you accidentally get it into your eyes because oils like coconut oil don’t burn. However, it’s critical to remember that’s not the case with this one. If you need a cleansing oil that will leave your skin smooth, supple, and hydrated, throw this one in your cart!
Lancome Bi-Facial Eye Makeup Remover For Sensitive Skin At Macy’s ($75)
Pros
- Gentle enough for sensitive skin
- Suitable for contact lens wearers
- Emollients refresh and moisturize delicate skin for plumping hydration you can feel
- Doesn’t feel greasy or sticky
- Suitable for all skin types
Cons
- Only recommended for the eye area. Using this on your entire face will get a bit too expensive
This is a must-have if all you need is a waterproof makeup remover for your eye area. It’s available in multiple sizes, so you don’t have to initially break the bank on a large bottle. Beware: after watching the way this makeup remover effortlessly lifts away stubborn, waterproof mascara, you’ll be addicted.
Honest Beauty Makeup Remover Wipes ($4)
Pros
- Gentle enough to use on the eye area
- Removes waterproof makeup
- Available in multiple sizes, from 7-count packs to 90-count packs
- Cruelty-free
- Won’t dry out your skin
Cons
- Makeup remover wipes are great for quickly removing makeup, but they are not a substitute for a complete cleansing and skincare routine
These makeup remover wipes are an excellent option for those nights when you are too tired for double-cleansing. They aren’t sustainable like The Original Makeup Eraser but are effective. They’re an excellent option to have when you’re on the go!
Raw Coconut Cream By RMS Beauty ($22)
Pros
- Cruelty-free and vegan
- Gluten-free and soy-free
- Moisturizing
- It can be used on the face, body, and eye area
- Removes makeup, including stubborn waterproof makeup
Cons
- Sells out quickly so it can be difficult to catch it in stock
This coconut cream is carefully crafted with raw, organic, unrefined coconuts to ensure you get all of the benefits coconut oil offers. Paris Laundry has exceptional standards regarding beauty products offered, and this raw coconut cream is no exception.
Vegan Bamboo Cleansing Clothes By Nudestix ($30)
Pros
- Works as a makeup remover, toner, and cleanser
- Softens the skin for a difference you can feel
- Vegan and cruelty-free
- Heavenly scent
- Compostable
- Great value for the price
- It leaves the skin feeling soft and smooth
Cons
- One swipe will remove light makeup. However, you may need a few swipes to remove waterproof makeup
These bamboo derived cleansing wipes are great for your skin! They’ll leave your skin feeling soft and smooth instead of dry and tight. They’re suitable for every skin type, including sensitive skin. If you’re not a fan of double cleansing, these are a great way to remove your makeup before completing the rest of your skincare routine.
Triple Oil Balm Makeup Remover And Cleanser By Sisley Paris ($140)
Pros
- Can be used for both the face and eye area
- The comforting formula soothes the skin while lifting away makeup and impurities
- Removes makeup and cleanses
- Suitable for all skin types
- Nourishes and protects the skin
- Hydrates and moisturizes the skin
- Doesn’t strip the skin
Cons
- The higher price is the only downfall of this product. However, once you start using it, you’ll realize it’s worth it. You can skip double-cleansing and use this single product to remove makeup, cleanse away dirt, and enjoy smooth, soft skin.
While the price can raise eyebrows, most people consider Sisley Paris products worth it. Products consistently receive rave reviews and are specially formulated to go above and beyond. If you want more than an essential makeup remover, this is right up your alley!
Final Thoughts
Finding the best waterproof makeup remover can be challenging, but it doesn’t have to be. We’ve compiled this comprehensive list of the best waterproof makeup removers to make it easier! Check out the rest of the site to discover awesome products, need-to-know makeup information, and the latest beauty hacks!
Related Articles
Are Makeup Remover Wipes Allowed On Planes
How To Take Off Waterproof Eyeliner Without Makeup Remover