ELF Eyeliner Pen Review

elf eyeliner pen review

ELF Cosmetics is known for providing drugstore makeup that’s high quality. Once you try some of their products, like the e.l.f. Poreless Putty Primer, you’re bound to wonder about the rest of them. I couldn’t help but try e.l.f. liquid eyeliner to see if I was in love with it. Check out whether you should pick it up with this ELF Eyeliner Pen Review! Keep in mind that e.l.f. has quite a few eyeliners available, and this review is for the ELF Waterproof Eyeliner Pen in brown. 

I participate in affiliate programs, including Amazon Affiliates, and may earn a small commission is products are purchased through links on the website. 

ELF Eyeliner Pen Ingredients

According to the ELF website, the ingredients are: 

Water (Aqua), Styrene/Acrylates Copolymer, Butylene Glycol, Laureth-20, Acrylates Copolymer, Phenoxyethanol, 1,2-Hexanediol, Caprylyl Glycol, Ethylhexylglycerin, Tocopheryl Acetate (Ve), Ppg-2 Butyl Ether, Ppg-2 Methyl Ether, Propylene Glycol,
Propylene Glycol Butyl Ether, Disodium Edta, Dc Black 2 (Ci 77266)

ELF Eyeliner Pen Swatch

elf eyeliner swatch

ELF Eyeliner Pen Pros Vs. Cons


e.l.f. Is Nice To Animals

All products from ELF Cosmetics are vegan and cruelty-free! 


This eyeliner pen had a deep, brown pigment. I only got the coffee color, but I was genuinely impressed! It had so much pigment I didn’t have to go over it after the initial line. 

Perfect For On The Go

The elf eyeliner pen dries so quickly that it’s perfect for those moments when you’re on the go. Not only is it a quick-drying eyeliner, but it’s also smudge-proof, waterproof, and easy to apply. A few swipes of color, and you’re good to go!

Perfect Consistency

I’ve had so many eyeliners over the years that it’s ridiculous. Many of them wind up being too watery or so thick that they’re a nightmare. That wasn’t a problem with this one, though. It was the perfect consistency to glide on nice and smooth. 

Easy Application

ELF eyeliner is for you if you’re struggling to make a wing with your eyeliner. The felt tip isn’t too flexible, but it’s not rigid. It has the perfect flexibility to make it easy to swipe it across the lid to create a flawless wing. 

Doesn’t Transfer Easily

If you have hooded eyelids, this is a great eyeliner to wear. It doesn’t transfer easily. You can keep your eyes closed until it dries, and you’re good to go. 

No Tugging

The eyeliner pen easily glides across your lids. It’s so smooth that it doesn’t tug on your eyelid. You can barely feel it on your face when you make a wing. 

Nice Finish

The eyeliner has a satin finish, but it’s not too glossy. Instead, it’s the perfect balance to create a look that you’re going to love. 


As with all e.l.f. products, this eyeliner is extremely affordable. You can find it everywhere, from drugstores to makeup stores like Ulta. Keep in mind that the price will vary depending on where you are. 


Not As Waterproof As Advertised

While the website states that this eyeliner is waterproof, it will not hold up in a downpour. However, it can withstand a few tears without running down your face. Remember that it’s not waterproof enough to wear to the beach or during rainy weather. The eyeliner washes off so easily that you must keep the weather in mind when wearing it. 

Smudges As The Day Goes On

This eyeliner was like a dream come true during the application process. However, it doesn’t hold up all day. As the day continues, you cannot help but notice some smudging. If you wear it on your bottom lid, you wind up with raccoon eyes before you leave the office. Setting spray helps but doesn’t completely solve the problem. 

Melts Off In Hot Weather

It’s great that this eyeliner can hold up for a bit, but that depends on the weather. Just like this one isn’t going to hold up during a lot of rain, it’s also going to melt off during hot and humid weather. If you’re in the middle of a heatwave, it’s best to stick with other types of eyeliner. 

In Conclusion

This isn’t a bad eyeliner pen, but it’s not the best. If you want to give it a shot, it’s worth it. The price point isn’t bad, and it’s excellent for beginners. You can check it out here!

If you’re not a beginner and want a drugstore eyeliner that will last, check out Milani eyeliner. 

For more eyeliner product reviews, tips and hacks, check out the rest of the site!

Related Articles

Best Drugstore Eyeliner

What Is Kajal Eyeliner

Gerard Cosmetics Eternal Eyeliner

Tarte Sugar Rush Eyeliner Review

Leave a Reply

The author does not in any way guarantee or warrant the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any message and will not be held responsible for the content of any message. Always consult your personal physician for specific medical advice. Information on this blog is for informational/entertainment use only. Please be advised that I do participate in affiliate programs, and may earn a commission if you purchase products by clicking on links on this website.